Updated Jun 4, 2025 · This post may contain affiliate links ·

Cobb Salad with Salmon and Everything but the Bagel Dressing

If you love everything bagels, shmear and lox, but (like me) you’d like a healthier alternative, look no further than my Cobb salad with salmon and everything but the bagel dressing! It incorporates the yum of the everything bagel experience into a delicious new interpretation of Cobb salad – fresh greens, smoky salmon, creamy avocado, crunchy red onions and salty capers.

JUMP TO RECIPE

This post contains affiliate links. See our privacy policy for more information.

Everything bagel cobb salad with smoked salmon and everything bagel chips

There’s just something about everything but the bagel seasoning, isn’t there? I don’t know who first thought to combine sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried garlic and onion and put it on top of a bagel, but I’m so glad they did. And I’d like to marry the person who decided to put it in a jar and sell it, this stuff has changed my life! And, apparently, my approach to Cobb salad.

This is, of course, a very non-traditional Cobb salad, but I suspect Mr. Cobb wouldn’t be angry about it. Just like my unorthodox take on the BLT in my BLT Kale Caesar, it doesn’t discard anything that’s great about the original. It’s got the same great combo of fresh, crunchy, rich, smoky, and sharp.

Ingredients for everything bagel Cobb salad with smoked salmon — **Note:** I used to include small balls of cream cheese rolled in everything but the bagel seasoning in this recipe. They are delicious, but I've found them to be unnecessary to the success of the dish. They also added a lot of trans fats. I've since re-developed the recipe to take them out, and a new photo is coming soon!

Smoked salmon and salad make a healthy pair

The biggest departure I’ve made from the traditional Cobb salad is smoked salmon. This switch really boosts the nutrition in this recipe, and cuts out the saturated fats found in chicken and bacon. Wild salmon is chock full of heart-healthy fats, vitamins, and minerals; so much so that it’s considered a superfood. It’s good for your heart, your eyes, your brain, your skin, your mood, your bones, your joints, and the list goes on and on. Even among the many healthy ingredients common in the Mediterranean diet, salmon is a superstar.

I love salmon any way I can get it, but smoked salmon is my favorite way of adding fish into my diet. It’s not inexpensive, but thanks to its bold, smoky flavor and meaty texture, a little goes a long way. It’s also easy to find, store, and prepare. If you can, make sure your salmon is wild-caught, and comes from a sustainable fishery. My local grocery store smokes their salmon in-house, but when I can’t get there I usually buy smoked salmon at Trader Joe’s or Costco.

Everything bagel yogurt dressing being whisked together

Yogurt and everything but the bagel seasoning tops it all off

I’m basically through with heavy, fatty, mayonnaise-based dressings. I’ve been making my own salad dressings for a decade, and I maybe go through a small jar of mayonnaise a year in my house. Maybe. Greek yogurt is my usual replacement, and its tart flavor and creamy texture are the perfect pairing with everything but the bagel seasoning and lemon. I also like that using yogurt and raw honey add a dose of probiotics to the dressing to support gut health.

My everything but the bagel dressing is pretty versatile too. You can change out the lemon juice with red wine vinegar, add a little Dijon mustard, or mix in some chopped capers for a salty/briny kick. You can also use less of whatever liquid you choose and turn it into a dip for your next veggie platter, or a spread for sandwiches.

Everything bagel salad with smoked salmon, everything bagel yogurt dressing, and everything bagel chips

Tips to make the best Cobb salad with salmon

Make sure your greens are fresh and crispy. Texture is really important in Cobb salad, and it begins with fresh, crispy greens. You can revive your greens by soaking them in a bowl of ice water for 20-30 minutes. I run them through a salad spinner to dry before using them. This also works well for the arugula in my arugula and roasted pepper salad.
Try less-than-hard-boiled eggs in your everything Cobb salad. Hard-boiled eggs are traditional, but over the last year I’ve become a fan of eggs with jammy yolks. Guess what, they are delicious in Cobb salad! I boil my eggs using this technique from AllRecipes, and I think a 7 minute boil is absolutely perfect.*
Take the bite out of raw onions. Raw onions are a little much for me, so I like to mellow them out a little. I slice them then put them in a bowl with some cold water and an ice cube, and soak them for 15-20 minutes. They come out crispy and sweet, but with less bite than they have before they are soaked.
Check whether your everything but the bagel seasoning has salt. If it already has salt, mix up your dressing without adding any additional salt, then taste and add by the pinch as needed.

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Q: What type of smoked salmon should I use in this salad?

The simple answer is, whatever smoked salmon you enjoy, is available to you, and fits within your budget. There are many types of smoked salmon, and my family tried this salad with hot smoked salmon, cold smoked salmon, and lox. We liked the hot smoked salmon best, but we honestly enjoyed them all. If you can, I encourage you to find smoked salmon that is wild caught from a sustainable source. If all you can find is farm-raised smoked salmon, I believe it’s safe to eat, and while it has a slightly different nutritional profile than wild salmon, it’s still healthier than eating no salmon at all.

This recipe will also work with fresh cooked salmon, canned salmon, and canned smoked salmon.

Q: Where can I find everything but the bagel seasoning?

Five years ago it was everywhere! Now it's not hard to find, but it's not as ubiquitous as it was. I buy my everything but the bagel seasoning at Trader Joe's. Newman's Own brand is often available in the spice aisle at my local Kroger supermarket, as well as on Amazon.

Everything bagel yogurt dressing being drizzled on everything cobb salad with smoked salmon.

More easy fish recipes from Parsley & Parm

Prep ahead and storage

All of the components of this salad can be prepped up to a day ahead, except the avocado. Store the components in separate airtight containers in the refrigerator. Bring the tomatoes to room temperature before assembling your salad. Prepare the avocado and add the dressing just before serving. It’ll keep for maybe a day once the dressing has been added, but mixed greens tend to break down once they are dressed, so I don’t recommend it.

Did you make this recipe?

Let me know with a comment and a rating below! Your feedback helps me become better at developing and sharing recipes that help my readers make healthier choices. If you loved this recipe, please consider sharing it on your favorite social media platform, recipe sharing site, or saving it on Pinterest.

Save Recipe Pin Recipe Print Recipe

5 from 21 votes